Beethoven, "Hammerklavier" Sonata / Yuja Wang

For English speakers, the popular title of "Hammerklavier" that Beethoven's sonata No. 29 bears may seem rather rude. That title could suggest the idea of a sonata in which the pounding of the piano is a necessity. Nothing could be further from that.
The title, which the work shares with the preceding sonata, is simply the German word for "pianoforte." Beethoven wanted to thank the English piano builder Broadwood, who had recently sent him a modern piano with swinging strings. It is for this modern piano that the sonata is written: Große Sonate für das Hammerklavier, its full title.

It is a cliché to say that this monumental sonata is the most respected and studied by music lovers, but at the same time, the least loved or liked of the 32 sonatas by the master from Bonn. Regarded as unplayable by many 19th-century pianists (with the remarkable exception of Liszt), it is the first sonata for which Beethoven added metronomic indications, specifying the speed at which it should be played.

The required speed

This requirement, added to those inherent to the craft, has led renowned performers to suggest that the master's metronome must have been damaged because the speed demanded seems unattainable. On the contrary, those who trust in the goodness of the artifact of those years claim that Beethoven simply created a work that is sustainable at a certain speed and no other. We believe that the truth is on the side of the latter.

The length

Lasting about 45 minutes at the required speed, it is the longest sonata written by the master and at the same time the most difficult. As for its structure, Beethoven returned this time to organize the sonata in four movements, which he had not done since 1802 (opus 31 No. 3).

Four movements

The initial allegro is introduced by a few measures whose most relevant characteristic is its rhythmic aspect.
It is followed by a brief scherzo of just under three minutes.
In opposition, the subsequent adagio (which here goes as the third movement and not second as was common) is one of the longest slow movements in all piano literature, about twenty minutes, and one of the most dramatic written by Beethoven: appassionato e con molto sentimento, the master noted.
The last movement is the most ambitious, the one containing the famous fugue, in three voices, whose theme or subject extends for ten bars (min 34:15, in this version) and not the typical two or three of the baroque fugue, thus raising the technical and interpretative demand to incredible extremes.

Dedication

Like so many others, the work is dedicated to Archduke Rudolph of Austria, the highest-ranking aristocrat and the most cultured of Beethoven's noble friends. Composed between the summer of 1817 and the autumn of 1818, it is inserted in the vital period of the master in which deafness is total and hopeless. It is in these circumstances that the master of Bonn will reach the highest point in the piano production of his last period.

Sonata No. 29 in B flat major, Op. 106

00:00 Allegro

11:24 Scherzo: Assai vivace

14:12 Adagio sostenuto - appassionato e con molto sentimento

31:50 Largo - Allegro - Fuga: Allegro risoluto

The rendition is by the brilliant Chinese pianist Yuja Wang, in a recital on May 14, 2016, at the legendary Carnegie Hall, where not for being in New York the audience does not cough between movements (Yuja didn't find it funny at all).

Liszt, Études d'exécution transcendante / No 12, "Chasse-neige"

Liszt's famous studies known today as Transcendental Études took the author a good number of years to finish. The first seed dates from when the author was fifteen years old, and already had pupils, in Paris. Ten years later, the author revised the twelve original studies and proceeded to intensify the technical difficulties, since at that time he was himself a piano virtuoso. The final version would be published in 1852 under the title Douze Études d'Exécution Transcendante, dedicated to his teacher, Karl Czérny.

For practicing, or a challenge?
In this way, Liszt added his contribution to the current custom of writing works for piano intended for the practice and improvement of technical skills on the instrument. The most prominent contribution to the tradition up to that time was Chopin's Etudes, in two series, opus 10 and 25, the first of them dedicated precisely to Franz Liszt. But unlike the Polish composer, Liszt's Études do not have such a clear didactic intention. They do not seem to be designed for the practice of this or that specific technical difficulty, but rather as a challenge to the already experienced performer.

Chopin vs Liszt
Thus, for example, it is a general opinion that in order to approach Etude No. 4, Mazeppa, one must first have the skill that allows you to play "double thirds" with ease. On the other hand, with Chopin's Etudes, a pianist with, let us say, a timid left hand, may well decide to spend some time preparing the Revolutionary Etude precisely in order to transform this "timidity" into gallantry.

Etude No. 12 in B-flat minor, "Chasse-neige"
The twelve Etudes are rather heterogeneous in their conception. There are those of "pure music" as well as "programmatic". To the latter category belongs the last of the series, the one Liszt called "Chasse-neige". ("Pure" or "programmatic", all bear evocative or descriptive titles except No. 2 and No. 10). It is one of the five that pose the greatest technical difficulties of the entire series. The title alludes to a sort of "snowstorm" although the music itself is rather more tempestuous than an ordinary snowstorm might suggest.

The rendition is by Ukrainian pianist Valentina Lisitsa.

Erik Satie, "Embryons desséchés", pour piano

The clever and witty Erik Satie gained the recognition of his peers (or anything resembling it) when he was well into his forties. And here his colleague and friend Maurice Ravel had a unique role to play. In 1911 the author of the famous Bolero organized a monographic concert in Paris with works by Satie. It was the only occasion on which the Parisian public attended an evening entirely dedicated to pieces by the composer, the same one who twenty years earlier had astonished a few and baffled others with his now famous Gymnopédies.

From then on, his solo piano music gained great momentum. He had long since passed his "cabaret" stage, but he had not forgotten his sense of humor. During 1912-13 a series of humorous compositions came to light, which he titled in a somewhat outlandish way, adding comments to the score for the performer and, in passing, ignoring the bar division lines. From that period are, for example, Deux Preludes pour un Chien, Descriptiones Automatiques, and Embryons desséchés.

Embryons desséchés, pour piano ("Desiccated embryos")
Barely six minutes long, the piece is made up of three even more extravagantly titled sections, taken from the names of invertebrate beings that Satie came across in a school encyclopedia. But, there are no mentions here about embryos, desiccated or not.

Erik Satie, in 1820
(1866 - 1925)

What you do find are "quotations" to works by other authors.
The second piece contains a quotation from Chopin. In the "comments" for the performer, we read: "And then they all began to cry (quote from Schubert's famous mazurka)". As far as we know, Schubert never wrote a mazurka (let alone a famous one). The real quote is to the Interlude of the Funeral March (Sonata in B♭ minor), clearly not by Schubert but by Chopin, with which Satie toys for a couple of bars.

The "expression guides"
And as usual, the score is not lacking in "character indications" with which the author ousted the usual tempo and expression indications, replacing them with, say: Light as an egg - Like a nightingale with a toothache - Moderately, I beg you - A little bit warm, and the like.

Sections

00:00  d'Holothurie

02:13  d'Edriophthalma (3:02, the "quotation" from Chopin begins)

04:42  de Podophthalma

The rendition is by Ukrainian pianist Dina Pisarenko, during a break in the rehearsal/recording of another work, with orchestra.

Beethoven, Sonata violin & piano "Spring"

Beethoven wrote ten sonatas for violin and piano in the span of fourteen years, from 1798 to 1812, although nine of them were born during a much shorter period, from 1798 to 1803, the year the famous "Kreutzer" Sonata was published. Almost ten years elapsed, then, between this famous ninth sonata and the last, of 1812, thus completing the corpus of ten sonatas that in the chamber works of the master from Bonn are graciously placed in second place in importance, only surpassed by the string quartets.

Sonata No 5 was composed between 1800 and 1801 when the beginnings of deafness were starting to worry him. Even so, it is a quiet and fruitful period for the master, established in Vienna since 1792. Composed along with Sonata No. 4, it is contemporary with the Piano Concerto No. 3 and the First Symphony.

"Spring" Sonata
Published in 1801, it is dedicated to Count Moritz von Fries, Beethoven's generous patron and recurrent dedicatee of his work (the Seventh Symphony would be dedicated to him). Also known as the "Spring" sonata, together with the Kreutzer they are the only two sonatas to bear the title with which they became popular after the composer's death.

Sonata No. 5 in F major, opus 24 - Movements
Its first sketches date from around 1795, so the Mozartian influence in it is somewhat visible, or if you prefer, "audible", in all the sections that make it up. This is a four-movement structure that Beethoven would use for the first time in this genre, although it should be noted that the added scherzo lasts a minute and a bit longer. Its complete audition takes just over twenty minutes.

00:00   Allegro – The violin sings, generously lyrical, over a delicate piano accompaniment.

11:51   Adagio molto espressivo – A nostalgic melody, first introduced by the piano.

18:10   Scherzo: Allegro molto – Deliberately asynchronous moments between the two instruments.

19:32   Rondo: Allegro ma non troppo – Perhaps the most "Mozartean" of the movements.

The rendition is by German violinist Anne-Sophie Mutter and American pianist Lambert Orkis.

Chopin, "Tragic Polonaise", op 44

 
Although everybody wrote polonaises (there are those of Telemann, Mozart and Schubert, and the path will be continued by Mussorgsky and Tchaikovsky) the most famous and outstanding ones are due to Chopin's inspiration. An important part of the Polish composer's life was occupied by the creation of works in the Polonaise form. The first was written at the age of seven; the last, in 1846, three years before his death. The one that concerns us today was written in 1840 and published in Paris the following year. It was once called "tragic polonaise" but such a calamitous epithet no longer seems necessary. After all, it is a dance. In addition, the year 1841 had begun one of Chopin's most fruitful periods.

A "mixed" polonaise
In spite of its name, it is a " compound " piece, that is, mixed, because in the most unexpected way Chopin inserts a tempo di mazurka in the very center of the piece. His friend Liszt will be pleasantly surprised by such an occurrence and will point this out in a review of its Paris audition. In his usual flowery style, he will note that: "... In the pages of the greatest composers we have seen nothing comparable to the impression produced by this passage, abruptly interrupted by a country scene, by a mazurka in an idyllic style, which has the fragrance of mint and oregano".

The Komar ladies
The work is dedicated to the youngest of the Komar sisters, prominent ladies of the Polish émigré community in Paris, and enthusiastic friends of art in all its forms. By this time, however, the sisters no longer had that surname. Ludmila, dedicatée of the Polonaise, is now Princess Ludmila de Beauvau, having just married Charles-Just de Beauvau-Craon. Her sister Delfina, although divorced from her Count Potocki, will still be recognized as Delfina Potocka. For her there will be also an attentive regard (she is his pupil): Chopin will dedicate to her his popular "Minute Waltz", in 1847.

Polonaise in F sharp minor, opus 44

Three clear sections, preceded by a fiery crescendo, are distinguished in the piece:

00:20   The polonaise proper, martial, haughty, provocative.

03:00   A long episode in triple eighth notes, which seems to simulate a drum roll.

04:35   In the middle, the unforeseen mazurka, inserted by Chopin in the heart of a vehement piece. Thanks to his genius, this interlude will lead to the resumption of the introduction (7:50) and the first rhythmic theme (8:01).

In Liszt's words, the piece ends "with a somber murmur that leaves the soul caught in a blanket of disconsolation." Hence, perhaps, the tragic connotation mentioned at the beginning.

The rendition, immaculate, is by the Canadian pianist Charles Richard-Hamelin.